As you know, the newborn baby spends most of their time sleeping per day- around 16 hours, so comfort and safety are always the priority of parents. With a high-quality crib mattress, it will help your little one sleep soundly during the night as well as develop both physically and mentally. There are so many brands and products on the market nowadays, so how you can choose the best one because you don’t know if the product is reliable or not.
For this reason, I have done the research for you and have put together some of the popular baby crib mattress reviews that will make your work easier when choosing a suitable baby mattress. Once you’ve read my honest best crib mattress reviews, there won’t be any more room for indecision.
List of The Best Crib Mattress Reviews
Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress
Whether you’re prepping a nursery for a new arrival or upgrading your toddler’s sleep setup, the Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress offers a winning combination of comfort, durability, and peace of mind. Made with high-density, breathable foam and a waterproof, machine-washable cover, it’s designed to meet the needs of busy parents who want safety without sacrificing softness. Certified by both GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US, this mattress is crafted to support healthy indoor air quality while giving your little one a firm yet cozy surface for restful sleep.
Key Features
- High-Density Foam Core: Supports proper spinal alignment and provides firm comfort suitable for infants and toddlers.
- GREENGUARD Gold & CertiPUR-US Certified: Ensures low chemical emissions and high material quality.
- Waterproof, Removable Cover: Soft to the touch, yet easy to clean—just unzip and machine wash when needed.
- Fits Standard Cribs and Toddler Beds: Sized at 52″ x 27.6″ x 4.5″ to work with most nursery setups.
- No Fiberglass or Flame Retardants: Built without harsh chemicals, making it a safer choice for sensitive sleepers.
- Trusted Brand: Manufactured by Storkcraft, a legacy name in baby furniture since 1945.
What We Like
- Unmatched firmness and comfort balance for newborns and active toddlers.
- Cover feels premium—not plastic or noisy—yet handles messes like a pro.
- Expands fully within 24–48 hours and maintains shape over time.
- Lightweight and easy to handle when changing sheets or cleaning.
- Strong customer feedback with consistently high ratings.
- Thoughtful packaging and simple setup process.
What We Don’t Like
- May take a full 48 hours or slightly more to fully expand after unboxing.
- Thicker fitted sheets are recommended for best fit due to mattress height.
Overall
The Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress strikes an ideal balance between practicality and comfort. With its firm support, top-tier certifications, and easy-clean design, it’s a standout choice for parents who want a crib mattress that checks all the right boxes—safety, comfort, and durability. Even with minor quirks, this mattress earns its place as a favorite in nurseries across the country.
Serta Perfect Slumber Dual Sided Crib and Toddler Mattress
The Serta Perfect Slumber Crib and Toddler Mattress strikes the right balance between sustainability, safety, and sleep quality. Designed with a firm, recycled fiber core and wrapped in a waterproof vinyl cover, this dual-sided mattress is built to serve newborns and toddlers alike. It fits snugly into standard cribs, expands quickly out of the box, and has all the trusted safety certifications parents seek. Whether you’re bringing baby home for the first time or transitioning to a toddler bed, this mattress is designed to grow with your child while providing consistent comfort and support.
Key Features
- Dual-Sided Design: One mattress, two stages—flip when baby becomes a toddler for lasting use.
- Recycled Fiber Core: Firm and breathable, made from sustainable materials like upcycled plastic bottles.
- Waterproof & Hypoallergenic Cover: Both sides are fully sealed with an easy-to-clean vinyl layer that resists moisture and allergens.
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified: Tested for low chemical emissions to support a healthier indoor environment.
- Square Corners: Ensures a tight fit in standard cribs and toddler beds for enhanced safety.
- Made in the USA: Built with quality materials under strict manufacturing standards.
What We Like
- Firm yet comfortable support suitable for both infants and toddlers.
- Eco-conscious construction using sustainable materials.
- Lightweight and easy to lift for sheet changes.
- Dual-sided design extends usability as your child grows.
- Excellent fit with no gaps—ideal for safe sleep.
- Durable vinyl cover holds up to regular cleaning.
What We Don’t Like
- Both sides feel similar in firmness to some parents.
- Vinyl cover may feel slightly less soft than fabric alternatives.
Overall
This crib mattress delivers everything parents need—support, hygiene, and eco-friendliness—wrapped in a design that adapts with your child. While the vinyl cover may not feel as plush as fabric, its durability and waterproof quality more than make up for it. With high ratings from thousands of parents, the Serta Perfect Slumber is a solid, dependable choice in the world of crib mattresses.
Dourxi Dual-Sided Crib Mattress
The Dourxi Dual-Sided Crib and Toddler Mattress is a thoughtful, budget-conscious solution for parents who value comfort, safety, and longevity. With a breathable, washable cover and dual firmness levels, it adapts as your baby grows—firm for newborns and slightly cushioned for toddlers. Built using eco-friendly materials and designed to fit snugly in all standard cribs and toddler beds, this mattress quietly delivers on the essentials of safe, sound sleep.
Key Features
- 2-Stage Design: Infant side is firmer for newborn support, while the toddler side offers gentle cushioning.
- Breathable Construction: Made with a fiber core that promotes airflow for safer, cooler sleep.
- Removable, Washable Cover: Zips off easily for machine washing—ideal for the inevitable messes of baby life.
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified: Tested for low chemical emissions to support healthier indoor air.
- Eco-Friendly Fill: Uses over 300 recycled plastic bottles to create the supportive fiber core.
- Universal Fit: Sized to fit standard cribs and toddler beds with snug, square corners for safety.
What We Like
- Clear labeling for infant and toddler sides makes setup simple.
- Excellent breathability—great for peace of mind with tummy sleepers.
- Soft cover doesn’t crinkle or feel plastic, yet still protects from spills.
- Easy to clean and lightweight enough for frequent sheet changes.
- Eco-conscious materials without sacrificing durability or comfort.
What We Don’t Like
- Some may find both sides feel similarly firm.
- Slightly thicker profile may require deeper fitted sheets.
Overall
The Dourxi crib mattress checks all the right boxes: safe, supportive, easy to clean, and designed to grow with your baby. It’s especially appealing for parents who want a breathable, sustainable option without splurging. While firmness may feel consistent on both sides for some, the overall quality and thoughtful design make it a standout in the crib mattress category.
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress
If you’re looking for a safe, no-fuss mattress that doesn’t break the bank, the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress is worth considering. Built with a high-density thermo-bonded fiber core, this mattress is firm enough for newborns and supportive enough for toddlers. With a waterproof vinyl cover and GREENGUARD Gold certification, it offers peace of mind while keeping cleanup simple. It’s a practical choice for families who prioritize safety, functionality, and affordability.
Key Features
- Firm Fiber Core: Provides consistent support for both infants and toddlers.
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified: Ensures low chemical emissions, contributing to healthier indoor air quality.
- Waterproof Vinyl Cover: Resists spills and messes while allowing for easy spot cleaning.
- Durable Build: Designed to retain its shape over time, making it great for everyday use.
- Universal Fit: Sized to snugly fit standard cribs and toddler beds (52” x 28” x 5”).
- Lightweight: Weighs only 8 lbs, making sheet changes easier for caregivers.
What We Like
- Excellent value for families on a budget.
- Lightweight and easy to lift or move.
- Firm support that’s ideal for safe infant sleep.
- Wipes clean with minimal effort—perfect for busy parents.
- Trusted certifications for peace of mind.
- Fits snugly in most cribs with no gaps.
What We Don’t Like
- Some find it firmer than expected, which may not suit all toddlers.
- Vinyl surface may not feel as plush as fabric-covered options.
Overall
The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress delivers reliable performance at an accessible price. It checks all the essential boxes—firm support, easy maintenance, and a safe design—making it a solid pick for both cribs and toddler beds. While not the softest on the market, its focus on practicality and safety makes it a dependable choice for growing families.
Modera Dual-Sided Memory Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress
If comfort, quality, and adaptability are what you’re after, the Modera Dual-Sided Memory Foam Crib Mattress delivers in all the right ways. Designed with two distinct sleep surfaces—one firmer for newborns and the other softer for toddlers—it adapts to your child’s needs as they grow. Wrapped in a breathable, velvety-soft cover that’s also removable and washable, this mattress combines modern function with sleep-focused comfort. It’s thoughtfully designed to fit standard cribs and toddler beds, offering a reliable, fuss-free option for growing families.
Key Features
- Dual-Sided Memory Foam: Firmer infant side for early development and a plusher toddler side for added comfort.
- Breathable, Hypoallergenic Cover: Soft to the touch, zippered, and machine-washable for easy upkeep.
- Supportive Foam Core: Quiet and spring-free construction eliminates noise while maintaining balanced support.
- No Chemical Odors: Expands without off-gassing, ensuring a safer sleeping environment.
- Universal Fit: Designed for standard cribs and toddler beds, offering a snug and secure fit.
- Lightweight Build: Easy to lift, rotate, and manage during sheet changes.
What We Like
- Baby sleeps soundly—many parents say their child sleeps through the night.
- Clearly labeled sides make setup intuitive.
- Comfortable yet firm enough for newborn safety.
- Silent design—no rustling or squeaky sounds.
- No strange chemical smell out of the box.
- Excellent value for the quality offered.
What We Don’t Like
- Some buyers expected it to be slightly thicker.
- Waterproof liner not included; separate pad may be needed.
Overall
The Modera crib mattress balances softness and support with thoughtful features like dual-sided memory foam and a removable cover. It’s a strong choice for parents who want a cozy yet safe sleep surface that transitions effortlessly from baby to toddler years. With excellent comfort and great feedback from real families, this one easily earns its place among the better crib mattresses out there.
Sealy Baby Firm Rest Antibacterial Waterproof Crib & Toddler Mattress
The Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib & Toddler Mattress offers a winning blend of dependable support and peace-of-mind hygiene features for growing babies and toddlers. With its firm posture-supportive design, reinforced waterproof cover, and an antibacterial surface, it’s engineered to keep little ones comfortable while helping parents stay ahead of life’s messes. Designed to fit snugly in standard cribs and toddler beds, this mattress comes from a trusted name that’s been helping families rest easier for generations.
Key Features
- Posture Support System: 204 premium steel innerspring coils provide firm, even support across the entire surface.
- Antibacterial Waterproof Surface: A reinforced vinyl cover resists stains, odors, and moisture while keeping germs at bay.
- Airflow Pocket Design: Promotes airflow without using small metal vents, maintaining freshness.
- GREENGUARD Gold Certified: Low chemical emissions help contribute to healthier indoor air.
- Fits Standard Cribs & Toddler Beds: Measures 52” x 27.5” x 5.5” with square corners for a safe, snug fit.
- Made in the USA: Constructed with quality materials and backed by a 20-year warranty.
What We Like
- Excellent firmness and support for proper spinal alignment in infants.
- Durable, easy-to-clean surface that resists leaks and messes.
- No odor or off-gassing when unpackaged.
- Built-in antibacterial properties offer added hygiene.
- Maintains its shape and firmness even with extended use.
- Strong coil construction provides long-term durability.
What We Don’t Like
- A bit heavier than foam mattresses, making sheet changes less convenient.
- The waterproof cover can feel a little firm or slick without a soft fitted sheet.
Overall
The Sealy Baby Firm Rest is a solid, dependable crib mattress designed for everyday use and long-lasting comfort. Its focus on support, cleanliness, and durability makes it a top choice for parents who want a mattress that keeps up with their baby’s development—without the hassle. If you’re after peace of mind in both safety and practicality, this mattress more than delivers.
Babelio Dual-Sided Crib Mattress
The Babelio Breathable Crib and Toddler Mattress blends supportive design with smart features that adapt to your baby’s development. Its dual-sided construction offers firmer high-elastic foam for infants and softer memory foam for toddlers, all wrapped in a soft, breathable cover. With a washable exterior and waterproof inner liner, it’s a parent-friendly choice that’s as practical as it is cozy. Designed with thoughtful airflow and spine support in mind, it’s a mattress that evolves with your child while maintaining a clean and comfortable sleep space.
Key Features
- Dual-Sided Foam Core: Infant side uses high-elastic foam for firm support; toddler side features slow-rebound memory foam for cushioned comfort.
- Breathable & Washable Cover: Knitted fabric is soft on sensitive skin, and it zips off for easy machine washing.
- Waterproof Liner: Beneath the cover, a non-woven liner protects against spills and accidents.
- Ventilated Design: Built-in air holes help regulate temperature and prevent overheating during sleep.
- Fiberglass-Free & Flame Retardant Safe: Passes flammability safety standards without harsh chemicals.
- Standard Fit: Measures 52” x 27” x 4.7” to fit most full-size cribs and toddler beds snugly.
What We Like
- Clearly labeled sides for infant and toddler stages.
- Very soft to the touch yet firm enough for newborn safety.
- Quiet material—no plastic crinkle or movement noise.
- Stays cool and breathable, especially during warmer nights.
- Cover holds up well to washing and drying.
- Fits securely in cribs with no shifting or gaps.
What We Don’t Like
- Some units may have a mild scent out of the packaging—airing out helps.
- Slightly thinner than others on the market, though still supportive.
Overall
The Babelio Dual-Sided Crib Mattress checks off all the essentials: comfort, cleanliness, support, and versatility. Its thoughtful construction ensures a cozy transition from infant to toddler, making it a reliable option for parents who want a quality sleep environment without overcomplicating bedtime. It’s a well-rounded pick that blends practicality with gentle comfort.
Modera Organic Cotton Dual-Sided Crib Mattress
The Modera Organic Cotton Dual-Sided Crib Mattress offers a thoughtful, sleep-enhancing design built to grow with your child. Featuring a firmer, supportive infant side and a plush, cooling gel memory foam toddler side, it provides both comfort and posture support through key developmental stages. The breathable, waterproof organic cotton cover adds a layer of softness while helping busy parents keep things clean with ease. From newborn naps to toddler bedtime routines, this mattress adapts while maintaining comfort, safety, and durability.
Key Features
- Dual-Stage Foam Design: One firm side supports infants, while the other is softer for toddlers with cooling memory foam.
- Organic Cotton Cover: Removable and machine washable; waterproof for protection from spills or accidents.
- Cooling Gel Layer: Helps regulate temperature on the toddler side for more comfortable sleep.
- CertiPUR-US & OEKO-TEX Certified: Made without harmful chemicals and verified for low emissions and high safety standards.
- Standard Crib Size: Measures 52” x 27.5” x 5.5” for a snug fit in full-size cribs and toddler beds.
- Ventilated Core: Built-in air channels help with breathability and moisture control.
What We Like
- Great balance of firmness and comfort on both sides.
- Organic cotton surface is gentle on sensitive skin.
- Cover unzips easily and holds up well in the wash.
- Dual firmness extends the mattress’s usefulness.
- Strong user reviews and parent testimonials.
- No odor or off-gassing noted upon unboxing.
What We Don’t Like
- Some reports of minor zipper defects, though rare.
- Slightly heavier than foam-only mattresses.
Overall
The Modera Dual-Sided Crib Mattress checks all the boxes: comfort, cleanliness, adaptability, and eco-conscious materials. With its high-end features and thoughtful construction, it offers peace of mind for parents and a cozy sleep surface for growing kids. It’s an excellent option for families who want quality without compromising on safety or comfort.
Sealy Baby Flex Cool 2-Stage Crib Mattress
The Sealy Flex Cool Crib Mattress offers a balance of trusted durability and thoughtful comfort, all wrapped up in a dual-stage design made to support your little one from newborn days through the toddler years. With 204 premium steel coils and breathable cotton layers, it provides firm, consistent support without overheating. The waterproof surface and Greenguard Gold certification add peace of mind for parents who care as much about safety as they do about clean, comfortable sleep.
Key Features
- 2-Stage Firmness: Firm support for infants on one side, softer cushioning for toddlers on the other.
- 204 Steel Coils: Orthopedic innerspring design promotes even weight distribution and durability.
- Breathable Cotton Cover: Quiet, natural, and gentle on baby’s skin, with built-in airflow pockets.
- Waterproof Protection: PVC-free barrier prevents leaks from soaking into the mattress.
- Greenguard Gold Certified: Meets rigorous standards for low chemical emissions and safe indoor air.
- Made in the USA: Crafted with high safety and quality standards.
What We Like
- Great breathability for temperature regulation.
- Built-in posture support without feeling overly stiff.
- Lightweight enough for changing sheets with ease.
- No chemical smell or off-gassing noted upon unboxing.
- Fits snugly into standard cribs and toddler beds.
What We Don’t Like
- Slight denting reported by a few users due to packaging, though it generally regains shape.
- Firmer feel may not be ideal for older toddlers who prefer extra softness.
Overall
The Sealy Flex Cool 2-Stage Crib Mattress delivers on what matters most: a safe, breathable, and supportive sleep surface that grows with your child. Its coil-based core gives it an edge in durability, while the breathable cotton and waterproof design ensure it stays fresh and comfortable through all of life’s early messes. It’s a reliable choice that brings long-term value to any nursery setup.
Serta Perfect Start Dual-Sided Crib and Toddler Mattress
When it comes to finding a reliable crib mattress that offers comfort, value, and peace of mind, the Serta Perfect Start Dual-Sided Mattress hits the mark. Designed with a sustainably sourced fiber core, it delivers a firm, supportive sleep surface for infants while providing enough flexibility to comfortably accommodate toddlers. The waterproof, stain-resistant cover is a lifesaver for inevitable accidents, and its Greenguard Gold certification makes it a safer choice for your baby’s sleeping environment. Lightweight and easy to clean, this mattress was made with both baby and parent in mind.
Key Features
- Dual-Sided Design: Firm support for infants and a comfy toddler-ready side as your child grows.
- Eco-Friendly Core: Made from upcycled plastic bottles, offering durable support while being environmentally responsible.
- Waterproof Vinyl Cover: Resists stains and moisture; both sides are protected so the mattress stays fresh with time.
- Greenguard Gold Certified: Tested for low chemical emissions to promote healthier indoor air.
- Fits Standard Cribs and Toddler Beds: Measures 52” x 27.5” x 6” with square corners for a snug fit.
- Made in the USA: Constructed under strict safety and quality standards.
What We Like
- Comfortable firmness that suits infants and toddlers alike.
- Easy to wipe clean with no lingering messes.
- Lightweight, making sheet changes quick and hassle-free.
- Excellent price-to-quality ratio.
- No off-putting smell straight out of the package.
- Quiet cover material—no rustling noises during the night.
What We Don’t Like
- No labels to clearly mark infant vs. toddler side.
- Some users found the surface slightly noisy without a mattress pad.
Overall
The Serta Perfect Start Dual-Sided Mattress is a strong contender for parents looking for value without sacrificing comfort or safety. With a firm feel, water-resistant cover, and eco-conscious materials, it’s designed for everyday practicality and lasting performance. While it may not have the bells and whistles of premium-priced models, it covers all the essentials beautifully—making it a trustworthy, straightforward pick for growing families.
Things to Consider When Buying a Crib Mattress
1. Firmness & Support
Infants need a firm, flat sleep surface for safety and proper development. A dual-sided mattress with a firmer infant side and softer toddler side gives you more longevity.
2. Breathability
Look for designs with ventilation channels, breathable cores, or organic cotton covers to help regulate temperature and reduce overheating risk.
3. Waterproof Protection
Accidents are inevitable. A waterproof or water-resistant cover—especially one that’s removable and washable—can be a game-changer.
4. Certifications
Products with certifications like GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US ensure low chemical emissions and safer materials for your baby.
5. Fit & Compatibility
Make sure the mattress fits snugly in your crib or toddler bed. Standard dimensions are usually around 52” x 27.5” x 5”–6”. Square corners are often preferred for a better fit.
6. Weight & Ease of Use
Lighter mattresses make changing sheets and cleaning much easier—especially during late-night diaper leaks.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Newborns need a very firm mattress to support spinal development and reduce the risk of suffocation. Avoid anything overly soft, even if it feels comfy to adults.
Absolutely. They’re designed with one firm side for infants and one softer side for toddlers, so you can use the same mattress for years.
It’s not recommended. Older mattresses may harbor bacteria, allergens, or lose their support. For safety and hygiene, a new one is best.
GREENGUARD Gold for air quality, CertiPUR-US for foam safety, and OEKO-TEX for textiles are common, reliable standards.
Even with a waterproof cover, a separate, washable mattress protector adds an extra layer of cleanliness and extends the life of the mattress.
Conclusion
When it comes to crib mattresses, safety, support, and ease of cleaning are key. Whether you prefer the natural feel of organic cotton, the cooling benefits of gel memory foam, or the classic firmness of an innerspring coil system, there’s a mattress to fit your needs and budget. All the products we’ve reviewed offer strong features—some lean more toward eco-friendly materials, others toward durability and dual-stage support. But whichever route you go, choosing a certified, snug-fitting mattress that supports your baby through their early years is one of the best decisions you’ll make for their comfort and well-being.
Hello, just wanted to say, I liked this post. It was practical. Keep on posting!