Thanksgiving brings everyone together, but finding a game that children, parents, and grandparents all want to play can be surprisingly tricky.
Some people love competitive games. Others would rather stay at the dinner table. And the younger kids may not be interested in learning complicated rules.
That’s where Thanksgiving Would You Rather comes in.
All you have to do is ask two questions and choose between them. Would you rather eat pumpkin pie for breakfast or have mashed potatoes for dessert? Would you rather cook Thanksgiving dinner or wash every dish afterward?
There are no right answers, and the explanations are often funnier than the choices themselves.
Whether you’re entertaining kids while dinner is being prepared or looking for a relaxed family game after the meal, these 60 Thanksgiving Would You Rather questions will give everyone something to talk about.
Table of Contents
How to Play Thanksgiving Would You Rather
Would You Rather is a simple conversation game where players choose between two options.
One person reads a question aloud, and everyone decides which option they would prefer.
For example:
Would you rather eat only pumpkin pie or only apple pie for dessert?
Players choose an answer and can explain their reasoning if they want to.
That’s the entire game.
What You’ll Need
Nothing! You can read the questions directly from this article.
If you’re playing with a large family, one person can act as the host and read each question aloud.
For a smaller group, take turns choosing questions.
Three Easy Ways to Play
- Take turns: Ask one person a question, then let them choose the next player.
- Everyone answers: Read a question and invite everyone to share their choice.
- Choose a side: Ask players to move to opposite sides of the room depending on their answers.
You don’t need to keep score. The goal is to have fun and discover how differently everyone thinks.
Thanksgiving Food Would You Rather Questions
Thanksgiving food is an easy starting point because almost everyone has an opinion about what belongs on their plate.
These questions work especially well while everyone is waiting for dinner or enjoying dessert.
- Would you rather eat pumpkin pie for breakfast or mashed potatoes for dessert?
- Would you rather have an entire Thanksgiving meal without gravy or without dessert?
- Would you rather eat only the crispy edges of stuffing or only the soft middle?
- Would you rather have sweet potatoes with marshmallows or mashed potatoes with extra butter?
- Would you rather eat Thanksgiving leftovers for three days or have your favorite Thanksgiving dish only once a year?
- Would you rather have apple pie or pumpkin pie as your only Thanksgiving dessert?
- Would you rather eat your entire Thanksgiving dinner with a spoon or with a fork?
- Would you rather help make the main dish or prepare every dessert?
- Would you rather have unlimited dinner rolls or unlimited slices of pie?
- Would you rather try a completely new Thanksgiving recipe or eat the same favorite meal every year?
- Would you rather eat your Thanksgiving meal as one enormous sandwich or have every dish served separately?
- Would you rather have Thanksgiving dinner at lunchtime or eat it late in the evening?
For younger children, start with questions that mention familiar foods. You can also replace a dish they don’t know with something they enjoy.
Funny Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions
These silly questions are designed for laughs. They’re especially useful when a family gathering needs a little energy.
- Would you rather have to gobble like a turkey every time someone says your name or waddle like a turkey whenever you enter a room?
- Would you rather wear a giant pumpkin costume all day or a turkey hat for an entire week?
- Would you rather have your hair turn orange for Thanksgiving or have your shoes squeak like rubber ducks?
- Would you rather be followed around by a friendly turkey or have a squirrel steal one of your socks every morning?
- Would you rather accidentally sit in a bowl of cranberry sauce or get a spoonful of mashed potatoes on your head?
- Would you rather have to announce everything you do in a dramatic voice or sing every time you ask for something?
- Would you rather have a pet pumpkin that follows you around or a talking apple that tells terrible jokes?
- Would you rather sneeze every time someone mentions pie or hiccup whenever you smell gravy?
- Would you rather have to dance before every bite of dessert or do five silly poses before leaving the dinner table?
- Would you rather find a turkey sitting in your favorite chair or discover that every chair in the house has been replaced with a giant cushion?
- Would you rather have a Thanksgiving parade float shaped like your face or a giant balloon shaped like your favorite snack?
- Would you rather have your family speak only in animal sounds for one hour or communicate entirely through silly dances?
If a question inspires a ridiculous explanation, let the conversation continue. You don’t have to rush through all 60 prompts.
Easy Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions for Kids
These questions use familiar activities and simple choices, making them useful for younger children.
For toddlers and preschoolers, read one question at a time and give them a chance to answer without pressure.
- Would you rather jump in a pile of colorful leaves or run through a field of bubbles?
- Would you rather decorate a paper turkey or paint a big pumpkin?
- Would you rather have a teddy bear picnic or a pretend Thanksgiving dinner with your toys?
- Would you rather find a tiny pumpkin in your garden or a giant autumn leaf outside your door?
- Would you rather build a house from blocks or make a pretend bakery?
- Would you rather help put napkins on the table or choose the music for dinner?
- Would you rather wear a sweater with a turkey on it or socks covered in pumpkins?
- Would you rather go on a leaf hunt or look for interesting clouds?
- Would you rather make a colorful Thanksgiving card or decorate a paper placemat?
- Would you rather listen to a funny story or make up a story with your family?
- Would you rather play a quiet guessing game or have a short dance party?
- Would you rather watch a Thanksgiving parade or help decorate the house?
How to Play With Toddlers
You don’t need to ask every question or insist that your child choose only one answer.
Start with two familiar options, such as:
“Would you rather draw a turkey or paint a pumpkin?”
They might point, say one word, or decide they want to do both.
That’s fine. For very young children, the activity is simply an opportunity to make choices and talk together.
Thanksgiving Family and Traditions Would You Rather Questions
These questions are ideal for a mixed-age group because they focus on the little decisions that make family celebrations different.
You may discover that half your family loves a quiet Thanksgiving while the other half would happily turn dinner into a giant party.
- Would you rather host Thanksgiving at your home or travel to visit relatives?
- Would you rather prepare dinner together as a family or let one person surprise everyone with the menu?
- Would you rather spend Thanksgiving in a cozy cabin or at a house beside the beach?
- Would you rather play games before dinner or after everyone has finished eating?
- Would you rather take a big family photo every Thanksgiving or record a short family video each year?
- Would you rather watch a parade in person or enjoy it from a comfortable sofa?
- Would you rather sit beside a different family member at every meal or keep your favorite seat every year?
- Would you rather make a handmade decoration each Thanksgiving or collect a new holiday ornament every year?
- Would you rather have a relaxed dinner with no schedule or a day filled with planned activities?
- Would you rather cook a family recipe exactly as it has always been made or give it a new twist?
- Would you rather spend the morning playing outside or stay indoors cooking and decorating?
- Would you rather end Thanksgiving with a family board game or a movie everyone chooses together?
These questions can also help families discover traditions they’d like to try in future years.
Thoughtful Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions
Would You Rather doesn’t always have to be silly. These questions encourage easy conversations about favorite moments, family time, and the things people enjoy.
Keep the mood relaxed. Nobody needs to share anything personal or explain an answer they would rather keep to themselves.
- Would you rather receive a handmade card from someone you love or spend an afternoon doing your favorite activity together?
- Would you rather revisit a favorite family memory or create a completely new tradition?
- Would you rather receive a thoughtful surprise or help plan a surprise for someone else?
- Would you rather spend a whole afternoon talking with relatives or play games together without keeping score?
- Would you rather save one photograph from every Thanksgiving or write down one favorite memory each year?
- Would you rather learn how to make a family recipe or hear the story of how it became a tradition?
- Would you rather take a peaceful autumn walk with someone you love or spend a cozy afternoon reading together?
- Would you rather make one large family craft or create individual crafts to exchange?
- Would you rather have a Thanksgiving filled with familiar traditions or try something new every year?
- Would you rather share your favorite holiday memory or listen to someone else’s?
- Would you rather help prepare a meal for someone or surprise them with a handmade gift?
- Would you rather remember Thanksgiving for the food you ate or the people you spent time with?
For younger children, you can simplify these questions by asking about familiar people and activities, such as whether they’d rather read a book with Grandma or play a game together.
Jump to the free printable game
Thanksgiving This or That: A Faster Version
If your family enjoys Would You Rather but wants shorter rounds, play Thanksgiving This or That.
The idea is the same, but the host says just two words or short phrases instead of reading a complete question.
Try these quick choices:
| Option A | Option B |
|---|---|
| Pumpkin pie | Apple pie |
| Cooking | Decorating |
| Parade | Family movie |
| Cozy sweater | Warm blanket |
| Board games | Outdoor games |
| Family photo | Family video |
| New recipe | Family favorite |
| Autumn walk | Afternoon nap |
Ask everyone to answer at the same time by pointing left or right, raising a hand, or simply saying their choice.
This version works well when you only have five minutes before dinner.
How to Make Thanksgiving Would You Rather More Fun
The basic game is entertaining on its own, but you can change the format depending on your family.
1. Play the Majority Game
Read a question and ask everyone to choose an answer silently.
Count to three, then reveal the choices at the same time.
Before answering, players can try to predict which option most of the family will choose.
Anyone who correctly predicts the majority earns one point.
If the group is evenly split, nobody earns a point for that round.
2. Guess Someone Else’s Answer
Choose one person to answer a question privately.
Before they reveal their choice, everyone else guesses which option they picked.
Ask the person to explain their answer if they want to.
This variation can be especially funny when family members think they know each other better than they actually do.
3. Vote With Your Feet
Designate one side of the room for Option A and the other for Option B.
Read a question and invite players to move to the side that represents their choice.
It’s a simple way to add movement to the game, especially when children have been sitting for a while.
Keep the space clear and let anyone who prefers to stay seated answer verbally or by raising a hand.
4. Let Everyone Invent a Question
After playing a few rounds, ask each person to create their own Thanksgiving Would You Rather question.
You might get some surprisingly creative choices:
“Would you rather have a turkey that can fly or a pumpkin that can sing?”
Encourage silly, imaginative questions rather than questions intended to embarrass someone.
When to Play Thanksgiving Would You Rather
One of the advantages of this game is that it doesn’t require a dedicated playing area.
It works well at several points during the holiday.
While Waiting for Dinner
Read a handful of easy questions while everyone is sitting together.
Five or six prompts may be plenty to keep the conversation going.
At the Kids’ Table
Choose the simple questions about animals, crafts, food, and favorite activities.
An older child or adult can read the questions aloud.
Keep rounds short so children can return to eating and talking whenever they want.
After Thanksgiving Dinner
Use the funny family questions when everyone is relaxing.
This is a good time for mixed-age groups because nobody needs to move around or prepare supplies.
During a Long Car Ride
Would You Rather can also help pass the time while traveling to visit relatives.
A passenger can read questions aloud while everyone answers.
Keep the driver focused on driving and avoid any version that requires looking at a screen or moving around.
How Many Questions Should You Play?
You don’t need to work through the entire list in one sitting.
For a quick dinner-table activity, five to ten questions may be enough.
For a longer family game, choose 20–30 prompts and invite people to explain their answers.
You can also save the remaining questions for another day.
The best conversations often happen when someone gives an unexpected answer, so there’s no reason to rush through every prompt.
More Family Games for Thanksgiving
If your family has finished a few rounds of Would You Rather and wants another activity, try a simple drawing game, a guessing challenge, or a classic card game.
For a quieter option after dinner, our easy card games for kids guide includes 15 games you can play with a regular deck of cards.
Choose something that fits the ages and interests of the people playing rather than trying to organize a full schedule of entertainment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Thanksgiving Would You Rather?
Thanksgiving Would You Rather is a conversation game where players choose between two holiday-themed options. Questions may involve food, family traditions, autumn activities, or silly imaginary situations. Players can explain their answers, but there’s no requirement to keep score.
What are some funny Thanksgiving Would You Rather questions?
Try asking whether someone would rather wear a giant pumpkin costume all day or a turkey hat for a week, or whether they’d rather have a talking apple or a pet pumpkin. Funny questions work well when both choices are imaginative and neither is too unpleasant.
Can toddlers play Thanksgiving Would You Rather?
Yes, with simple choices and adult help. Ask about familiar things, such as drawing a turkey or painting a pumpkin. Younger children can point, say a word, or choose both options. The activity doesn’t need strict rules to be enjoyable.
How do you play Thanksgiving Would You Rather at the dinner table?
Choose one person to read a question aloud, then let everyone answer in turn or reveal their choices together. You can play while waiting for dinner or after the meal. No cards, movement, or additional supplies are required.
Is Thanksgiving Would You Rather the same as This or That?
Both games ask players to choose between two options. Would You Rather usually uses complete questions and encourages explanations, while This or That often uses quick choices such as pumpkin pie versus apple pie. You can switch between the formats during the same game.
How many players do you need?
Two people can play, and the game also works with a large family. For bigger groups, ask everyone to vote at the same time so nobody has to wait through a long round of individual answers.
Do you need printable Thanksgiving Would You Rather cards?
No. You can read the questions directly from this article or copy a few onto paper. Printed cards may be convenient for a party, but they’re not necessary to play.
Final Thoughts
Thanksgiving Would You Rather is one of those games that works because it asks so little of everyone.
You don’t need a big setup, complicated instructions, or a family full of competitive players. Just ask a question, make a choice, and see where the conversation goes.
Start with a few easy food questions, add some silly ones for the kids, and bring in the family questions when everyone is ready for a more relaxed conversation.
You might learn something new about a relative, discover a surprising family disagreement about pumpkin pie, or simply share a few good laughs.
And that’s a perfectly good way to spend part of Thanksgiving together.
Free Printable Thanksgiving Would You Rather
Get all 60 Thanksgiving questions in one printable game sheet. Perfect for family gatherings, the kids’ table, and holiday parties.
Thanksgiving Would You Rather
How to play: Read each question aloud and choose one option. Share your reasons if you like. There are no right or wrong answers!
Thanksgiving Food
- Would you rather eat pumpkin pie for breakfast or mashed potatoes for dessert?
- Would you rather have an entire Thanksgiving meal without gravy or without dessert?
- Would you rather eat only the crispy edges of stuffing or only the soft middle?
- Would you rather have sweet potatoes with marshmallows or mashed potatoes with extra butter?
- Would you rather eat Thanksgiving leftovers for three days or have your favorite Thanksgiving dish only once a year?
- Would you rather have apple pie or pumpkin pie as your only Thanksgiving dessert?
- Would you rather eat your entire Thanksgiving dinner with a spoon or with a fork?
- Would you rather help make the main dish or prepare every dessert?
- Would you rather have unlimited dinner rolls or unlimited slices of pie?
- Would you rather try a completely new Thanksgiving recipe or eat the same favorite meal every year?
- Would you rather eat your Thanksgiving meal as one enormous sandwich or have every dish served separately?
- Would you rather have Thanksgiving dinner at lunchtime or eat it late in the evening?
Funny Thanksgiving Questions
- Would you rather have to gobble like a turkey every time someone says your name or waddle like a turkey whenever you enter a room?
- Would you rather wear a giant pumpkin costume all day or a turkey hat for an entire week?
- Would you rather have your hair turn orange for Thanksgiving or have your shoes squeak like rubber ducks?
- Would you rather be followed around by a friendly turkey or have a squirrel steal one of your socks every morning?
- Would you rather accidentally sit in a bowl of cranberry sauce or get a spoonful of mashed potatoes on your head?
- Would you rather have to announce everything you do in a dramatic voice or sing every time you ask for something?
- Would you rather have a pet pumpkin that follows you around or a talking apple that tells terrible jokes?
- Would you rather sneeze every time someone mentions pie or hiccup whenever you smell gravy?
- Would you rather have to dance before every bite of dessert or do five silly poses before leaving the dinner table?
- Would you rather find a turkey sitting in your favorite chair or discover that every chair in the house has been replaced with a giant cushion?
- Would you rather have a Thanksgiving parade float shaped like your face or a giant balloon shaped like your favorite snack?
- Would you rather have your family speak only in animal sounds for one hour or communicate entirely through silly dances?
Easy Questions for Kids
- Would you rather jump in a pile of colorful leaves or run through a field of bubbles?
- Would you rather decorate a paper turkey or paint a big pumpkin?
- Would you rather have a teddy bear picnic or a pretend Thanksgiving dinner with your toys?
- Would you rather find a tiny pumpkin in your garden or a giant autumn leaf outside your door?
- Would you rather build a house from blocks or make a pretend bakery?
- Would you rather help put napkins on the table or choose the music for dinner?
- Would you rather wear a sweater with a turkey on it or socks covered in pumpkins?
- Would you rather go on a leaf hunt or look for interesting clouds?
- Would you rather make a colorful Thanksgiving card or decorate a paper placemat?
- Would you rather listen to a funny story or make up a story with your family?
- Would you rather play a quiet guessing game or have a short dance party?
- Would you rather watch a Thanksgiving parade or help decorate the house?
Family and Traditions
- Would you rather host Thanksgiving at your home or travel to visit relatives?
- Would you rather prepare dinner together as a family or let one person surprise everyone with the menu?
- Would you rather spend Thanksgiving in a cozy cabin or at a house beside the beach?
- Would you rather play games before dinner or after everyone has finished eating?
- Would you rather take a big family photo every Thanksgiving or record a short family video each year?
- Would you rather watch a parade in person or enjoy it from a comfortable sofa?
- Would you rather sit beside a different family member at every meal or keep your favorite seat every year?
- Would you rather make a handmade decoration each Thanksgiving or collect a new holiday ornament every year?
- Would you rather have a relaxed dinner with no schedule or a day filled with planned activities?
- Would you rather cook a family recipe exactly as it has always been made or give it a new twist?
- Would you rather spend the morning playing outside or stay indoors cooking and decorating?
- Would you rather end Thanksgiving with a family board game or a movie everyone chooses together?
Thoughtful Thanksgiving Questions
- Would you rather receive a handmade card from someone you love or spend an afternoon doing your favorite activity together?
- Would you rather revisit a favorite family memory or create a completely new tradition?
- Would you rather receive a thoughtful surprise or help plan a surprise for someone else?
- Would you rather spend a whole afternoon talking with relatives or play games together without keeping score?
- Would you rather save one photograph from every Thanksgiving or write down one favorite memory each year?
- Would you rather learn how to make a family recipe or hear the story of how it became a tradition?
- Would you rather take a peaceful autumn walk with someone you love or spend a cozy afternoon reading together?
- Would you rather make one large family craft or create individual crafts to exchange?
- Would you rather have a Thanksgiving filled with familiar traditions or try something new every year?
- Would you rather share your favorite holiday memory or listen to someone else’s?
- Would you rather help prepare a meal for someone or surprise them with a handmade gift?
- Would you rather remember Thanksgiving for the food you ate or the people you spent time with?




